Power and Promises: What's Driving the Epstein Scandal?

The Epstein scandal very well may finally be Trump’s undoing, and it is a monster he created himself. Afterall, this is a man who has long promoted conspiracies, including those involving the deep state and pedophiles.  For years there has been buzz in the MAGA world about Epstein’s suicide and who is on his underage girl-loving list of friends and clients, a conspiracy largely originating from QAnon.  QAnon and Trump are peas in a pod.  QAnon were the ones who believed Trump was their messiah, the Great Awakening, the man who would expose the truth of a secretly controlled government, media, and other institutions who trafficked children for sexual pleasure. 

They consistently ignored the evidence that exists today, even without the benefit of seeing many of the investigative documents, that Trump himself was at least at one time a close, personal friend of Epstein.  Instead, the assumption was that Trump, upon his reelection, would put into place people like Kash Patel and Pam Bondi who would immediately release the files that would prove the Democrats and others were indeed part of a secret cabal who abused children for sport.  It’s a story of intrigue that isn’t going away.  It speaks to our fascination with power, elitism, and those to which the rules do not apply. 

That the files have not been released, that the lists that Pam Bondi declared were sitting on her desk no longer exist, and that Kash Patel has backtracked and now states that Epstein did commit suicide, all make this a story with staying power.  The MAGA base is angry.  Their savior and leader is betraying them and that perpetuates this saga.  The longer this story stays in the spotlight, the more damaging it becomes to Trump.

Trump would not be the first megalomaniac whose fall from grace was the product of his own actions.  Look no further than Romania’s Nicolae Ceausescu.  Like Trump he was a cult of personality.  He also demanded respect on the international stage and sought to overhaul the country’s economy, much as Trump has done.  Ceausescu’s end was just as dramatic as his reign—he and his wife were executed for genocide and other alleged crimes, after a trial that lasted only 55 minutes, by firing squad in 1989.

With Trump we have all the typical ingredients of a dictator bent on suppression of political rivals, human rights abuses as we are seeing with the treatment of immigrants, curtailing free speech and the free press, and an exaggerated response to dissent and protests.  And like those dictators who came before him, his reign will eventually come to an end, driven at least in part by his own actions, as was the case with Nicolae Ceausescu and so many other dictators.  The oppressed eventually do rise forth, even if in the MAGA world they viewed Trump not as the oppressor, but rather as their liberator.  They got the leader they wanted, and they are still oppressed.  The Epstein scandal is the opportunity to strike.

Within the Republican party exists support for Trump on a bell curve.  You have your die-hard MAGAs—the Marjorie Taylor Greenes, Stephen Millers, and Glenn Becks of the world—where conspiracies, hate, and a thirst for power flow through their blood.  In the middle (and I’d argue the majority of Republicans), you have those who personally may not subscribe to the MAGA rhetoric, but go along with it because they don’t want to deal with the political repercussions of appearing to be out of step with their dear leader and they want to reap the benefits of those who voted for Trump.  On the other end of the spectrum, you have those who are marching to the beat of their own drummer and will largely make political decisions as they see fit devoid of undue influence. 

Given that then, I wonder if there is a not unsubstantial pool of Republicans who see this Epstein saga as the opportunity to finally free themselves from Trumpism.  Is support of releasing the Epstein files a demand for justice and exposing the powerful who may have victimized young girls as so many in the MAGA world have sought for many years, or is it an opportunity to finally rid the party of a man who has dominated at the expense of the democracy Americans hold dear?  Are there Republicans working behind the scenes to see Trump finally fall?

Trumpism was always going to die from within.  It had to.  The death of the movement would never have any legitimacy unless it destroyed itself.  Trump’s success has always been about capitalizing on perceived injustices to the average, working American and using that to seize power.  Concerns about job losses, rising costs, and a system of government that thrives off the backs of the working stiff, are all legitimate.  Trump has played into the fears and desires of Americans in what amounts to manipulation at the expense of truth and facts.  Trump says aloud, in a manner that belies his privileged upbringing and adulthood, what the disenfranchised are thinking.  That drives his appeal and that is what has enabled him to stay in power, giving him grace even when very real evidence exists that Trump is not a good man.

As country, we also have not produced an alternative to Trump, which has contributed to his staying power.  No Democrat or Republican has matched or answered Trump’s dominance, his magnetism, or his ability to spin the narrative.  Someone will come in behind Trump.  Who that will be remains to be seen, but the ability for someone to step forth is infinitely easier if Trump becomes a persona non grata with the American people and there are many, including (maybe especially) those in the Republican party, who would love to see that happen.

Quietly, but deliberately, we have seen and will continue to see an erosion of Trump support as it becomes more apparent Trump has betrayed his faithful. That he is one of those same elite who used his power to abuse the vulnerable, will be the excuse to abandon him, but it isn’t the sole reason for his downfall.  Epstein is that one last snowflake that triggers the avalanche.  More than that, as those Trump himself has put into place to expose the evildoers do not deliver on Trump’s promises, dissatisfaction with the man himself will grow.  Trump will try to make some of those people the fall-guy or gal.  I fully expect his support for Pam Bondi, Kash Patel, and others to wane as the heat continues. 

He will release some information, particularly those documents that support his narrative that it was the Democrats who were in bed with Epstein, but will that be enough?  That tactic has worked in the past, but Trump is largely a lame duck.  There isn’t a third term coming.  He may want one, but the man is old.  When the “perfect physical specimen” of a man is using his health to distract from the scandal, he’s showing us he’s weakened, literally and figuratively.  As with all of those at the top, there is always someone looking to topple them.  Epstein provides that chance.

Epstein may spell the end of the Trump era, but as with most extremist movements, don’t expect it to go quietly.  The most stringent of adherents will be devastated, angry, and without direction.  They’ll be jockeying for influence and power.  All these things suggest there will be violence.  It is a hard (red) pill to swallow that the man in which many have couched their hopes for the future has failed them.  But it is a step more easily done when supporters can point to the lack of meaningful change in their lives.  When Trump can no longer deliver on his false promises, it makes it easier for those who once supported him to look elsewhere for someone to rescue them.  The Epstein saga is the excuse needed to betray their leader.

Read on Substack